This album starts off with “Renato Dall’Ara (2008)” which has these weird effects to start us off. I’m used to Los Campesinos! kinda just starting up their albums strong, but here we have these weird affects muffling up their sound heavily and slowly lifting. When things clear up though it’s business as usual for Los Campesinos! for the most part, and they certainly don’t sound too bad. Los Campesinos! still have their pop oriented style in tact and it’s very jolly, but man is it just me or is their energy seriously lacking? It’s certainly not as invigorating or as eye popping, thankfully it’s catchy enough to keep your interest. But almost immediately we’re noticing a bunch about Los Campesinos!. For one, they aren’t nearly as quirky as they used to sound, and overall this is just much more straight up indie rock sounding. It’s still far from bad, and the the group vocals come off nicely and all. I just honestly wish this was a little more explosive. “Sad Suppers” is up next, and in all honesty this is certainly a big leap in the right direction. Here, at the very least Los Campesinos! has the energy going for them, not to mention some of the smaller details that make up the Los Campesinos! sound are coming back slowly. The riff is catchy, there’s just enough attitude, and the vocals are pretty much where they should be at this point in their career. To put it simply, “Sad Suppers” at the very least SOUNDS like the band. They still sound a little off as far as their energy goes, but like I said this is a big improvement. Also, here Los Campesinos! sound much more mature, an end up coming up with one of their catchiest and most solid hooks on the entire album. “Sad Suppers” is also one of the simpler tracks here, but to be honest at this point in their career it’s what I want to hear from them. Up next is the first track I’ve heard from this album, “I Broke Up In Amarante”. For starters, it certainly has the spunk and the energy I've been looking for. The performance here though, man is it just the exact opposite. In some bizarre twist, I feel like I’ve come across some new Pop Punk album, and not a good one either. Thankfully, the chorus certainly adds a ton, mostly because they’re gang-like vocals are always done so well. Overall though, “I Broke Up In Amarante” barely even sounds like Los Campesinos!, not even instrumentally. I love these instrumentally energetic performances from Los Campesinos! a whole lot, but this one seriously doesn’t click one bit. I feel like Los Campesinos! are trying to sound all rough around the edges and heavier but that’s just not who they are. Sadly, “A Slow, Slow Death” is even worse. Instrumentally, this is certainly more along the lines of what I like to hear from them, but now they’ve slowed it down way too much. If you haven’t figured it out yet, this album is seriously all over the place. More than anything, this album has made me miss the frantic, noisy performances from early Los Campesinos! albums more. Again, this track is just OK, but I still feel like I’m listening to an entirely different band. Los Campesinos! used to be just so much fun to listen to, packed with quirky instrumentals to fit the band’s quirky personality. I understand that the band is getting up their in age and they matured a bit, but there certainly can be other ways of doing that, because this is painful. There are nice moments on “A Slow, Slow Death”, I certainly dig the chorus (mostly because it’s actually lively and not so damn depressing), the horns are nice as well. But holy hell, do Los Campesinos! really need to get their act together quick.
No, Los Campesinos! really don’t pick it up just yet, because “The Fall Of Home” sounds like a mixture of Weezer and American Football. Sure, I dig both of those acts, but I’m not here to listen to any of them, I want to listen to Los Campesinos!. At this point I barely know what the band is even doing anymore, this is the polar opposite of what I was expecting. Earlier I mentioned how Pop Punk some of this sounded, now this just sounds straight up Emo. Not even the sweet bells that pop up that have LITERALLY become synonymous with the Los Campesinos! sound can save this one. I think there are some nice harmonies that pop up here and there, and I certainly dig the strings, but man this isn’t what I showed up for. Their early recordings were so exciting and groundbreaking, this is just straight up depressing. And once again, this track was a damn single! I don’t get it. Then, I hear songs like “5 Flucloxacillin” and my heart just drops. After all of these “Just alright” tracks, Los Campesinos! deliver a track that’s so good that it’s probably going to be one of my favorite rock singles of the year. Everything just clicks on “5 Flucloxacillin”, and it’s easily one of the best tracks the band has done in years, and in every way this touches my soul. The backing vocals almost have a heartland feel to them, and they’re near perfect. And while no, this isn’t upbeat or super exciting, this is probably the most sincere sounding track on here, hell it’s even a little quirky from time to time. In a lot of ways, this is the perfect Los Campesinos! song. Then we have the chorus, which may be the most joyous on here, which almost sounds like some old school Arcade Fire. It’s a fantastic track in every way. Thankfully, Los Campesinos! do indeed keep things a little less dreary with “Here’s to the Fourth Time!”. Los Campesinos! continue to at least sound like themselves, but is it just me or does it sound like they’re seriously ripping off Passion Pit here. “Here’s to the Fourth Time!” isn’t the worst thing going on on this album, my only real issue is it’s a little too cheery to an almost suffocating degree. This is still much better then their earlier attempts at Emo or whatever the hell that was. The vocals here at least stick with you, and I seriously like a ton of the instrumentals. Moving on! “For Whom the Belly Tolls” may just be the second best track here, seriously why is it so hard at this point for Los Campesinos! to just take this sound and stick with it. This track is upbeat, has a little attitude to it, it’s confident and most of all it’s catchy. And while it may not be as hectic and upbeat as I remember, this is still a fantastic sound for the band. Can they stick with it though?
“Got Stendhal’s” starts off the last little leg of our journey. The intro here is actually pretty stunning to be honest. I honestly wasn’t expecting such a pleasant intro, it really ends up working for Los Campesinos!. Of the slower tracks here, this is certainly one of the better ones. The instrumental here is constantly building, the icy synths floating through the background are stunning, and despite the tone of this song the vocals are strangely bouncy. All around the track is put together absolutely wonderfully, hell this doesn’t even sound like it belongs on this album, maybe on one of their last few. I’m still kinda getting that Passion Pit vibe, but it’s certainly not enough to bring this one down. Plus, those group vocals in the last minute are absolutely stunning. Sadly up next Los Campesino’s completely drop the ball and end up offering up one of their most bland tracks yet. “A Litany/Heart Swells” starts off just as stunning as the last track, but quickly becomes incredibly boring. Sure, this track has the atmosphere down and even a little emotion. But everything else within literally does nothing for me to the point where I barely remember anything about this track. The drums are kinda epic in parts, but everything else is just a blur. Thankfully, Los Campesinos! do end off the album on a slightly better note. “Hung Empty” may be the most upbeat track on here, it almost has a synth-pop feel to it. It still beats me on why the hell they went for so many slower tracks earlier. While “Hung Empty” is far from perfect, at the very least it’s fun to listen to. At it’s core this track really shows Los Campesinos! going back to their more pop oriented sound, which certainly isn’t a bad thing. Not to mention, “Hung Empty” ends up having one of the catchiest choruses on the entire album. Why couldn’t the rest of this album be as carefree and fun?
Rating 7.1/10
Give A Listen To: "Sad Suppers", "5 Flucloxacillin", "For Whom The Belly Tolls", "Got Stendhal’s"
Overall Thoughts: I wouldn't go as far as to say this is a bad album, I just expect so much more out of Los Campesinos! at this point. There are some fantastic tracks here, but there are just as many that come off really awkward (example: all these weird genre shifts). In the future though I think Los Campesinos! could still certainly cone out with a real knockout.